Tragedy is one of the hardest things Christians deal with in terms of theology. How do we reconcile a loving, and all-powerful God, with the terrible sadness we see all around us. The problem gets worse the more personal the suffering is. Whole books have been devoted to explaining suffering in this world. Whole books have been devoted to tearing down those theories in those other books. I’ve read plenty of them, myself, trying to find the answers someone would eventually ask me for. More often than not I am left disappointed in what I read. One writer will give one answer that is what they see as the one reason for all the evil and suffering in the world. But upon reflection, it fails to explain more than a few scenarios. Another writer will work hard to point out all the flaws in several theories and conclude that God is not all-good, or not all-powerful, or that God is not the God we thought He was. But He is, so that doesn’t work for me. At the end of the day all I really have to hang onto is a loving, all-good and all-powerful God.
I read once, in a book written by a pastor of some 25 years or so, that as a minister walking into a tragic situation you had better have answers. “I don’t know” cannot be an option. I think that’s a lot of bunk. I think people are looking for ministers who are real, who have faults, who don’t pretend to be know-it-alls, and aren’t afraid to not know, and to simply cry with them. I remember when my uncle died in a car accident and my aunt put her arms around me asked “why”, over and over. I said nothing. Nothing at all. Not because I didn’t have the answer (I didn’t), but because that was what I felt the Spirit directed me to do. Just be silent. So, sorry folks, but I don’t know.
The problem of suffering is complex. On the one hand suffering is suffering and pain is pain. On the other hand there are many things that cause suffering and so there are many types of suffering. Or at least many reasons for it. It truly is a case -by-case kind of thing. It could be a matter of consequences. It could be a matter of free will. But so many times it seems that there cannot possibly be a reason. That’s when it seems the most unfair. We ask why God would do such a thing. I don’t believe that God does these things. But then the question changes to why He allowed it. Even if He didn’t send it, then He must have allowed it. Sometimes there’s an easy answer. If you chain-smoked three packs a day for 30 years and got lung cancer that’s probably not God’s fault. But so many times, it’s so much harder than that.
A friend of ours recently gave birth to a little boy. He was extremely premature and weighed less than a pound. It was a difficult pregnancy and the doctors were worried about a several things before he was born. I prayed, my wife prayed, our church prayed. But the little boy died when he was 14 days old. So I got to asking “why”. What happened to “ask and ye shall receive? Where was all this “hedge of protection” stuff all the motivational preachers are writing books about? Why would God allow this family, this baby, to go through this? I found myself feeling angry with God. But then I thought: perhaps instead of looking for God in this little boy’s death, I should be looking for God in this little boy’s life.
I spoke about God being all-good, all-loving and all-powerful. But I had forgotten all-knowing. Perhaps God wasn’t in the death, but in the pre-mature birth. Perhaps God knew the alternative outcome and wanted to give this family as much time as was medically possible. It sounds like cold reasoning and maybe it is, but it’s all I’ve got. And isn’t ALL life precious? Infinitely precious? Aren’t even two weeks of life more precious than not existing at all? But it certainly doesn’t answer all the questions. It doesn’t answer the question of why He allowed the conception, then. Infact, it doesn’t answer a lot of questions. But how far back could we go with that? Probably all the way back to creation. The first word in the Bible, in Hebrew, is B’reishit. The first letter of that word (and therefore the Bible) is a Hebrew character that looks something like a backwards “C”. And, since Hebrew is read right to left, the “C”’s open end faces the rest of the sentence, with the closed end facing the margin. The sages taught that from this we are to learn that what came before creation is closed to us. That we are to focus on what is ahead of us. These are the only things we can change anyways. So I think at some point we need realize that we can only go so far with our questions. That at some point we have to accept the “I don’t know”. And in accepting it, maybe we can begin to look for God in the miracles and not so much in the tragedies. Maybe. I don’t know.